Used Star-Max Griddles: What Star Documents, and What We Removed

What Star's manual and the CPSC recall notice say about used Star-Max gas griddles like the 636TD, and the price, part and lifespan figures we removed.

Updated: 2026-10-26

The Star-Max 636TD is a 36 inch thermostatic gas griddle. We could not find a Star document written for the 636TD itself, so this page leans on Star's current manual for the Star-Max 600 Series and on Star's page for the 636TF, its thermostatic sibling. Where we describe a 636TD, treat it as a description of the family, and confirm against the data plate.

What we removed, and why

We removed every dollar figure on the old page: the sibling used prices, the new prices, the auction anecdote and the thermostat part prices. We removed the lifespan ranges, the plate warping discussion, the claim about water in the burners, and the repair-video stories. None of these is stated in a Star document or in the CPSC notice. Anyone selling you a 636TD at a stated "market price" is quoting a sibling or a guess, and so were we.

Which control type you have

Star's 600 Series manual covers several variants, and it sets out the control types in one line: "CONTROL TYPE Manual Control Thermostat Control Thermostat & Safety Pilot Control Thermostat & Safety Pilot Control with Chrome Plate". That is the MF, TF, TSPF and TCHSF columns. The practical point for a buyer is that the control type changes what can go wrong and what parts you need, so read the data plate and write the exact model in your offer.

On the thermostatic 636TF, Star's product page describes a "Modulating thermostat inserted into the griddle plate". The manual says what a working one does: "Set the thermostat dial knob to the temperature desired. After a short preheating period, the thermostat will automatically maintain the selected temperature." You can test that. Run the griddle at a mid setting for fifteen minutes with a surface thermometer on the plate. If the plate climbs and stays at the top, or swings widely around the dial setting, the control is not doing what Star says it should. A click from the knob proves nothing about accuracy.

The plate is meant to slope

Star's leveling instruction tells the installer to "adjust the legs to create 1/8 inch slant from back to front on the griddle plate." So a slight slope toward the grease trough is correct and not a sign of damage. Judge a plate by its surface and by how it heats, not by whether it sits dead level. For burned-on residue Star says "If there is an accumulation of burned on grease and food, the griddle should be thoroughly scoured and reseasoned." A plate with heavy carbon buildup is a cleaning job, but it also tells you how the previous owner treated the machine.

The recall

The 2006 Robertshaw recall covers griddles. The notice says the recalled controls "are installed on natural and liquid propane (LP) gas commercial cooking equipment, such as ranges, pasta cookers, deep fat fryers or griddles." It names two brand lists. For the flame switches: "Keating (of Chicago), PMI Food Equipment Group, Vulcan, Southbend, Blodgett, Toastmaster, and Wolf Range." For the safety valves: "Bari (Restaurant and Pizzeria), Southbend, and Blodgett." Star Manufacturing is not named on either list. That says nothing about other recalls, and we did not search for any this pass. For the Robertshaw recall the notice adds, "The model and/or serial numbers can be found on the cooking appliance identification plate located on the appliance," so a griddle that was rebranded or built into a line with another maker's gas controls is still worth a look at the plate.

Inspection list

  1. Read the data plate for the exact model and control type.
  2. Run it fifteen minutes with a thermometer and compare the plate to the dial.
  3. Look at the plate surface for carbon buildup, deep gouges or visible waviness.
  4. Ask where the machine was kept and whether the burners have ever been wet. We have no Star statement on this, so it is a question and not a documented fault.
  5. Ask for a written quote for a replacement thermostat for that exact model before you set your price.

Sources

Every quotation above was fetched from the document linked here and matched word for word on 2026-10-26.