A used gas fryer can be a good buy, but the figures that circulate for it, including the ones on this page until now, mostly came from dealer pages and forums. This version keeps what Frymaster, Pitco and the CPSC say, and removes the rest.
What we removed, and why
We removed every price, new and used, and every part price and part count. We removed the thermopile millivolt threshold, the gas valve cost ranges, the lifespan figures, the burner design comparison and the stories about clogged burner ports. None is stated in a Frymaster, Pitco or CPSC document, and one figure was looser than Frymaster's manual, as noted below. We have no used-price data for these fryers that we can trace.
What the manuals say
Frymaster MJ45. Frymaster's Master Jet manual says "MJ45 Series fryers are freestanding fryers designed for high-volume frying. MJ45 frypot capacity is 40-50 pounds." Our earlier page said 50 pounds, which is the top of that range. The manual also describes a U-shaped burner: "The U-shaped burner should light and burn with a strong, blue flame." Our earlier page called the burner design tube-fired. We could not source that and removed it. For a buyer the useful part is the flame. Light the fryer in front of you and look. A strong blue flame is what the maker describes.
Lighting the pilot. Frymaster's procedure is "Continue to hold the knob in for about 60 seconds after the flame appears on the pilot." The manual then says the pilot should remain lit when the knob is released. If a fryer will not hold its pilot after a proper hold, something in the pilot circuit is not doing its job, and you should ask who diagnosed it.
Pitco SG14. Pitco's installation and operation manual covers "Covering Models SG14C, SG14, SG14R, SG14T, SG18 SG1824, SGC" and includes a "Thermostat Calibration Millivolt thermostats" procedure, so a millivolt control is part of this family. It gives two thermostat checks you can do at an inspection. One is a warning sign: "If the burners do not turn off at the lowest thermostat setting, the thermostat could be defective." The other is a method: "Let the fryer cycle 4 to 6 times before checking the temperature," and then compare a thermometer in the oil with the dial. We did not find a Pitco manual for the 35C+ itself. Pitco does publish a "35C+ & 45C+ GAS FRYER PARTS MANUAL", so you can look up a part number there, but we make no claim here about how the 35C+ is controlled.
Oil is a safety issue as well as a wear issue
Pitco's manual warns that "The use of old shortening can be dangerous as it will have a reduced flash point and be more prone to surge boiling." It also says "NEVER leave the fryer in standby overnight." Frymaster recommends a boil-out cleaning: "Frymaster recommends boiling out the frypot each time the oil or shortening is changed." So the questions for a seller are about habit. How often was the oil changed, was the frypot boiled out, and was the machine left in standby? Dark, thick oil in the pot is a sign the answers are poor. No manufacturer document we found gives a lifespan, so we give none.
Safety devices
Frymaster's cleaning instruction says "When cleaning the inside of the frypot, avoid striking the high limit thermostat and temperature probe or operating thermostat". That tells you there are a high limit and a probe inside the pot and that they can be damaged by rough cleaning. At inspection, look at them for dents or bent probes, and ask whether the high limit has been tested. We removed the temperature we had printed for it because we could not source it.
The CPSC 2006 Robertshaw notice says the recalled controls "are installed on natural and liquid propane (LP) gas commercial cooking equipment, such as ranges, pasta cookers, deep fat fryers or griddles." We did not match any of these fryer brands to that notice, so check the ID plate against the Robertshaw list if the fryer is from the 2005 to 2006 period.
At inspection
- Light the pilot yourself and hold it as the manual says. Watch whether it stays lit.
- Watch the burner. Walk away from a flame that is not steady and blue.
- Check that the burners shut off at the lowest thermostat setting.
- Look at the high limit and probe for damage.
- Ask for oil change and boil-out records.
- Get a dealer quote for the exact part you suspect before you set a price.
Sources
Every quotation above was fetched from the document linked here and matched word for word on 2026-10-26.
- Master Jet Series Atmospheric MJ35, MJ45, MJCF and J1C Gas Fryers manual 8196003 (Frymaster), checked 2026-10-26
- Master Jet Series Atmospheric MJ35, MJ45, MJCF and J1C Gas Fryers manual 8196003 (Frymaster), checked 2026-10-26
- Master Jet Series Atmospheric MJ35, MJ45, MJCF and J1C Gas Fryers manual 8196003 (Frymaster), checked 2026-10-26
- Master Jet Series Atmospheric MJ35, MJ45, MJCF and J1C Gas Fryers manual 8196003 (Frymaster), checked 2026-10-26
- Master Jet Series Atmospheric MJ35, MJ45, MJCF and J1C Gas Fryers manual 8196003 (Frymaster), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Installation and Operation Manual for Gas Fryers L20-195 R7 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- 35C+ & 45C+ Gas Fryer Parts Manual L22-229 (Pitco), checked 2026-10-26
- Robertshaw Controls Co. Recalls Gas Controls Installed in Commercial Cooking Appliances for Fire Hazard (U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission), checked 2026-10-26